U2, 1987 · key of D major · 110 beats per minute
D, A, B minor, G, one bar each, from start to finish: the I – V – vi – IV chart never changes. Everything is in the dynamics, from almost nothing to full volume.
Transposed to C major, the song uses the chords beginners learn first:
The whole song: C | G | Am | F
D | A | Bm | G
U2: four chords, one loop, the whole song
With or Without You sits on four chords in D major from start to finish, D – A – B minor – G, one a bar: I – V – vi – IV, with no bridge and no detour. The easiest chart to remember of all the songs here.
What makes the song is the build: the record starts almost in silence and ends at full volume, on the same chords. On piano, play softly first, in the middle of the keyboard, then louder and wider.
The song: U2, 1987 · D major · ≈ 110 BPM
Each chord held for its full length, right hand alone: time to find its notes. The computer plays the bass.
The same chords, struck on every beat, with the bass in the left hand: the song’s pulse.
The loop four times in a row, starting soft and ending loud: that’s the record’s shape, without changing a single chord.
Drop it into the Studio: it writes its piano sheet music and scrolls it along the real record. Slow it down, loop a passage, play along. See the Studio
In the original recording, With or Without You is in D major. To make it easier, this page also gives it in C major: the same progression, with fewer chords to learn.
4 chords, in the order they come: D, A, Bm, G.
The record is at 110 beats per minute, in 4/4: four beats to the bar. So a bar lasts about 2.2 seconds.
Yes (very easy): in C major, it takes 4 chords, all among the six chords of C major beginners learn first.
Played as simple chords in C major, all 4 chords are in the free course: you know them all by the end of lesson 43, “The major triad”.
How to accompany a song on piano · Turn an MP3 into piano sheet music · Learn piano for free